Experimental database — not agricultural advice. Learn more

Back to Screener
Pawpaw

Pawpaw

Asimina triloba GRIN 4485

fruitperennial Zone 5–8

Pawpaw (Asimina triloba) is North America's largest native edible fruit, a perennial understory tree producing custard-like fruit tasting of banana-mango. Suitable for Zones 5-8 with adequate frost-free days and chill; low-input crop needing cross-pollination.

19/30

Crop Snowflake Score

Gross Revenue
$4,200

/acre

Net Return
-$2,000

/acre

Price Trend
increasing
Establishment Cost
$25,000

/acre

Crop Insurance
None
Years to Production
5

years

Overview

Growing Season

Plant
Early spring (dormant, after budbreak) – Early spring (dormant, after budbreak)
Harvest
Sep-Oct – Sep-Oct
Frost-free days
160+
GDD (base 50°F)
2,600

Yield

Typical yield
9,000 lbs/acre
Productive lifespan
30 years
Years to full prod.
5
Labor
340 hrs/acre
95%

Market Fit

5/6

Active Regional Buyers

No buyer on record for this crop in the catalog's buyer network.

Price Trend Stable/Up

3-year price trend recorded as "increasing".

Supply Below Demand

2 of 6 documented channels rate viability "strong". Sold into regional rather than national markets, fruit supply here generally trails that demand.

Multiple Buyer Channels

3 of 6 documented market channels rate viable or better (farmers_market, direct_to_consumer, restaurant). Multiple independent routes to market.

Value-Added Potential

3 viable direct-market channels (farmers_market, direct_to_consumer, restaurant). Supports value-added and margin capture beyond wholesale.

Market Growth Projected

Specialty fruit segment; consumer demand for regionally grown specialty produce has been expanding.

Market Channels

farmers_market · Primary fresh-fruit outlet. Limited shelf life (2–3 days at room temperature) makes short, direct supply chains ideal. Novel native fruit attracts curious consumers who pay a premium for the unique custard-like flavor.
direct_to_consumer · Farm stands, on-farm sales, and pre-order/pickup arrangements work well. Frozen pulp shipped to consumers via mail order extends the selling window beyond the 4–6 week harvest.
restaurant · Chefs feature pawpaw in seasonal desserts, ice cream, and cocktails when available. Demand is concentrated in farm-to-table operations; relationship-building and reliable delivery are essential.
csa · Short harvest window and rapid post-harvest softening make pawpaw a novelty CSA addition rather than a staple. Best deployed as a one-week feature share with clear handling instructions for members.
wholesale · Fresh wholesale is essentially impractical due to fruit fragility and short shelf life. Frozen pulp wholesale to bakeries, craft brewers, distillers, and ice-cream makers is the only viable wholesale model.
retail · Local independent groceries and food co-ops occasionally stock fresh pawpaw during peak season. Mainstream supermarket distribution is rare. Value-added retail (frozen pulp, jam, ice cream) is more accessible.

Climate Fit

4/6

Hardiness Zone Match

Crop tolerates zones 5-8; region spans 5-6. Overlaps.

GDD Sufficient

Crop needs 2600 GDD (base 50F); region accumulates 2500+. Short by 100.

Precipitation Compatible

Crop needs ~32 in; region receives ~38 in/yr. Compatible, irrigation available as supplement.

Frost-Free Season OK

Crop needs 160 frost-free days; region provides ~180. Sufficient.

Chill Hours Met

Perennial. Region's zone 5-6 winters deliver well over 1,000 chill hours, ample for temperate perennials.

Climate Trend Favorable

Crop spans 4 hardiness zones (5-8). Narrow range (4 zones) offers less buffer if the region warms out of 8.

Fit by region

The farm matcher, run on each region's cited climate normals. Soil and site are not included here; add your own on the match page.

Match your farm
Finger Lakeszone 5b/6a · 2,200 GDD · 145 frost-free days · 38.29" rain

Limited by heat accumulation (gdd base 50f), frost-free season. 6 criteria evaluated, 1 not yet researched; 80% cited.

Possible
55/100
Hardiness zoneHeat accumulation (GDD base 50F)Frost-free seasonRainfallHigh-severity risksKnown buyers
Lake Erie Concord Grape Beltzone 6a/6b/7a · 2,923 GDD · 185 frost-free days · 41.09" rain

No limiting condition found. 6 criteria evaluated, 1 not yet researched; 80% cited.

Strong fit
100/100
Hardiness zoneHeat accumulation (GDD base 50F)Frost-free seasonRainfallHigh-severity risksKnown buyers
Chautauqua Uplands (Allegheny Plateau)zone 6a · 2,364 GDD · 158 frost-free days · 45.93" rain

Limited by heat accumulation (gdd base 50f), frost-free season. 6 criteria evaluated, 1 not yet researched; 80% cited.

Strong fit
77/100
Hardiness zoneHeat accumulation (GDD base 50F)Frost-free seasonRainfallHigh-severity risksKnown buyers

Climate envelope & site

What the farm matcher compares your conditions against.

Climate envelope

Hardiness zone
5–8
Frost-free season
160+ days
Heat (GDD base 50°F)
2,600+
Winter chill
400+ hours
Rainfall
15.7–59.1 in/yr

Below the minimum, irrigation is needed; above the maximum the crop fails.

Soil pH target
5.5–6.5

Extension lime target; within 1.0 of it is correctable.

Site & structure

Spring frost at bloom
high sensitivity
Needs cold-air drainage
yes — avoid frost pockets
Shade tolerance
partial
Mature height
30 ft
Rooting depth
not yet recorded
Wind exposure tolerance
low
Workable slope
not yet recorded

Height, rooting depth and shade tolerance are the inputs an alley or guild layout needs.

Soil Compatibility

Soil Texture

silt_loam (ideal)loam (ideal)sandy_loam (suitable)clay_loam (suitable)silty_clay_loam (suitable)loamy_sand (marginal)sand (marginal)clay (marginal)sandy_clay_loam (suitable)silty_clay (poor)

Drainage

well_drained (ideal)moderately_well_drained (ideal)somewhat_excessively_drained (suitable)somewhat_poorly_drained (marginal)excessively_drained (marginal)poorly_drained (marginal)very_poorly_drained (marginal)

Infrastructure Fit

4/6

Equipment Compatible

3 of 11 documented equipment items are crop-specific (27%) against a catalog median of 29%. Most needs are met by general row-crop or orchard equipment.

Storage Available

3 documented storage routes; at least one (Fresh cold storage) is reachable with conventional on-farm or third-party facilities.

Irrigation Compatible

Requires ~32 in. High water demand — may exceed typical farm irrigation capacity.

Field Layout Suitable

Suited to the small-to-mid-size fragmented parcels typical of the region.

Labor Availability

Labor requirement not recorded. Catalog 75th percentile is 250 hr/ac.

Processing Proximity

No processing or cooperative buyer on record for this crop; product would need to travel or be sold fresh.

Equipment Requirements

planting

Tree-planting tools / augerRequired

For establishing container-grown trees at 6–10 ft in-row spacing with rows 15–20 ft apart.

Deep (14 in.) tree-pot containers (propagation)Optional Specialized

Deep tree-pot containers accommodate pawpaw’s taproot when raising seedlings for grafting/transplanting.

general

33% shade cloth on supports (establishment)Optional Specialized

Seedlings and grafted trees under 24 in. benefit from shading during the establishment year; suspend 33% shade cloth on supports.

Pruning tools (central-leader training)Required

Central-leader training in the first years is critical for canopy light; later remove crossing/rubbing limbs.

Soil-test kit / pH amendmentsOptional

Soil test before establishment and correct deficiencies; target pH 5.5–6.5 with annual N at ~100 lb/acre.

irrigation

Drip tape or microsprinkler systemRequired

Pawpaws are not drought tolerant; supply 1–2 in. water/week via drip on either side of the trunk or microsprinkler over the root zone.

spraying

Shielded/backpack herbicide sprayerOptional

Maintain a 3–4 ft weed-free band; shield trunks and remove suckers before postemergent herbicide application to avoid systemic uptake.

cultivation

Mulch / weed-barrier fabricOptional

A 3–4 ft weed-free band on either side of trees can be maintained with mulch or weed-barrier fabric instead of tillage (roots are shallow).

harvesting

Hand-harvest totes / basketsRequired

Fruit skin is delicate and bruises easily; pick when flesh first softens and check trees daily during harvest.

post_harvest

Refrigerated cold storage (32–40°F, 90–95% RH)Required

Refrigerate as soon as possible after harvest to avoid fermentation and browning; quality still declines after a few weeks.

Fruit pulper (deseeding for frozen pulp)Optional Specialized

A fruit pulper removes seeds and skin before storing frozen pulp for ice cream, smoothies, beer and baked goods.

Storage Requirements

Fresh cold storage

Temperature

39–41°F

Humidity

85–95%

Max Storage

21 days

Ambient short-term display

Temperature

60–72°F

Humidity

60–80%

Max Storage

3 days

Frozen pulp

Temperature

-10–0°F

Max Storage

365 days

Financial Return

2/6

Revenue Above Average

Gross revenue $4,200/ac vs catalog median $6,000/ac. Below median.

Input Costs Acceptable

Input cost not recorded; not penalising. Catalog 75th percentile is $6,300/ac.

Payback Period OK

Reaches full production in 5 years. Long establishment — capital tied up 5 years before full return.

Insurance Available

No federal crop insurance recorded for this crop; risk sits with the grower.

Revenue Per Labor Hour

Cannot compute — labor hours not recorded. Catalog median is $13.16/hr.

Grants/Subsidies

Fruit crops are eligible under the USDA Specialty Crop Block Grant Program.

Economics Breakdown

Avg Price/Unit$4/per lb
Gross Revenue/Acre$4,200
Annual Operating Cost—/acre
Establishment Cost$25,000/acre
Total Input Cost—/acre
Net Return/Acre-$2,000
Revenue/Labor Hour—
Crop Insurance Not available

Source: University of Kentucky Center for Crop Diversification — Pawpaw (2025)

Risk Profile

4/6

Manageable Pest/Disease

1 of 11 documented risks are high-severity (9%) against a catalog median of 36%. Risk load is manageable by conventional IPM.

Market Diversified

3 viable market channels of 6 documented. Not dependent on a single outlet.

Low Establishment Risk

5 years to full production at $25,000/ac establishment cost. Multi-year capital commitment before first full return.

Climate Resilient

Tolerates zones 5-8 (4 zones). Moderate tolerance; sensitive to years at the edge of its range.

Regulatory Burden Low

No crop-specific licensing or reporting regime beyond standard food-safety and pesticide rules.

Diversifies Portfolio

Adds a fruit revenue stream distinct from the region's grape-dominated base.

Known Risks

disease

Leaf spot complex (Mycocentrospora asiminae, Rhopaloconidium asiminae, Phyllosticta asiminae)moderate

Fungal leaf-spot complex on leaves and fruit; begins as tan spots with brown borders that develop into dark brown to black lesions and can crack open, damaging fruit. Favored by extended leaf wetness.

Armillaria root rot (Armillaria mellea)high

Oak root rot fungus reported as a devastating disease of mature plantings, killing established trees.

Sooty blotchlow

Superficial fungal blemish appearing as sooty black blotches on fruit surface during warm, humid, rainy periods; mostly cosmetic.

pest

Pawpaw peduncle borer (Talponia plummeriana)moderate

Tortricid moth whose larval stage burrows into flower peduncles, stems and roots, destroying large numbers of flowers and reducing fruit set.

Asimina webworm moth (Omphalocera munroei)moderate

Larvae tie leaves together with webbing and feed within; infested foliage eventually dies.

Japanese beetle (Popillia japonica)low

Adults emerge in late spring and skeletonize foliage over a 4–6 week feeding period.

Spotted wing drosophila (Drosophila suzukii)low

Vinegar fly that can infest ripening/soft fruit; one of several secondary fruit pests of pawpaw.

weather

Spring frost damage to flowersmoderate

Blooms are vulnerable to late spring frost, especially in low-lying frost pockets, which can kill flowers and eliminate a fruit crop.

environmental

Deer damage (fruit and trunk)low

Deer will not browse leaves or twigs (acetogenins deter them) but will consume fallen fruit and can damage trunks by rubbing.

market

Limited fresh markets and high perishabilitymoderate

Markets are limited (though expected to grow) and fruit is highly perishable at room temperature, lasting only a few days, which constrains fresh distribution.

regulatory

Value-added/frozen product food-safety compliancelow

Selling frozen pulp or value-added products requires compliance with local health regulations.

Nutritional Yield

USDA FoodData Central
Profile based on Pawpaw, peeled, seeded, raw (fruit form)
Edible mass per acre2,041 kg
Computed: 9,000 lbs × 0.45 kg/unit × 50% edible

Macronutrients

NutrientPer 100 gPer acre
Protein1.2 g23,512 g
Fiber3.3 g67,358 g

Key micronutrients

Iron
0.1 mg /100g
1,525 mg / acre
Calcium
9.9 mg /100g
202,278 mg / acre
Potassium
220.9 mg /100g
4,508,911 mg / acre
Vitamin C
27.6 mg /100g
563,359 mg / acre
Folate
116.1 mcg /100g
2,369,781 mcg / acre

Uncertainty: Per-acre values are estimates that compound the yield range, edible-fraction assumption, and a single representative nutrient panel. Treat them as order-of-magnitude planning numbers, not nutritional advice. Confidence: high.

Ecosystem Services

Biodiversity

  • Sole larval host for the zebra swallowtail butterfly
    high

    Pawpaw is the obligate host plant for the zebra swallowtail butterfly (Eurytides marcellus); acetogenins in the leaves protect the larvae from bird predation.

    Applies when: native butterfly present in region
    Evidence: Extension guidance·Confidence: high
  • Agroforestry understory component and wildlife food
    moderate

    Suited to agroforestry systems as a partial understory tree (compatible even under black walnut); provides wildlife food and is not preferred browse for goats and other herbivores.

    Applies when: agroforestry / mixed native plantings
    Evidence: Extension guidance·Confidence: medium

Erosion control

  • Riparian buffer and streambank stabilization
    moderate

    Naturally found along stream banks and in forest groves; works well as a riparian buffer tree, helping stabilize soils near waterways.

    Applies when: riparian or buffer plantings
    Evidence: Extension guidance·Confidence: high

Pollinator support

  • Forage for fly and beetle pollinators
    low

    Flowers are pollinated by flies and beetles (lady beetles, nitidulid beetles, bottle flies, march flies), supporting saprophytic and generalist pollinator guilds rather than bees.

    Applies when: flowering
    Evidence: Extension guidance·Confidence: high

Soil health

  • Arbuscular mycorrhizal associations
    low

    Increasing soil organic matter at planting encourages associations with arbuscular mycorrhizae that improve nutrient uptake.

    Applies when: organic matter added at establishment
    Evidence: Extension guidance·Confidence: medium

Cultivars

Named varieties and what the sources say sets each apart. A cultivar-specific zone, chill or maturity figure overrides the species value above.

Grows With / Avoid Near

Documented interactions with other catalog crops — shared pests, allelopathy, rotation effects, alley and understory pairings — for companion, guild and rotation planning. Plan a combination with Pawpaw →

Grows with (5)

Tolerates (1)

Direction matters: a rotation benefit of A before B says nothing about B before A. Interactions are documented pairs only; absence is a research gap, not a clean bill.

Nearby Buyers

Radius from Lake Erie Concord Grape Belt:
No registered buyers for this crop within 50 miles.

Data Sources

Every data point on this page is traceable to its source. Below you'll find the complete provenance trail — which sources were used, when data was last verified, and a full change history.

Primary sources: Data sourced from Cornell Cooperative Extension, Penn State Extension, USDA resources, and regional research.

Economics data year: 2025 · Basis: lake erie View economics source →

75 tracked changes across 10 data categories

Core Crop Data

Oct 1, 20261 entry
Region-neutral cleanup audit
Apr 16, 20261 entry
internal revert
Apr 16, 20261 entry
Apr 16, 20261 entry
Apr 16, 20264 entries

Storage Requirements

Soil Preferences

Drainage Preferences

Crop Picker

by Every.Farm

A stock-screener-style tool for comparing crops anywhere in the world.

Your Location

  • Lake Erie Concord Grape Belt
  • NY / PA
  • United States
  • Zone 6a

Change this from the header to screen crops for a different region.

Experimental research database. AI-assisted, may contain errors. Not formal agricultural, financial, or planting advice. Verify with your local extension service before making decisions.

© 2026 Every.Farm · Data for informational purposes only.