Experimental research database. Information here is AI-assisted, may contain errors, and is not formal agricultural advice. Verify against your local extension service before making planting or financial decisions. Learn more

Crop Pickerby Every.Farm
Back to Screener
Broccoli

Broccoli

Brassica oleracea (Italica group)

vegetablebiennial Zone 3–10

Cool-season cole crop (Brassica oleracea, Italica group — the same species as cabbage, cauliflower, and kale), grown as an annual for its immature green flower head (the central crown plus, in some types, secondary side shoots). Adapted to USDA hardiness zones 3-10 with timing and cultivar selection; it is a frost-tolerant crop that develops best heads under steady cool conditions of roughly 60-70F and is prone to quality defects when it heads during hot weather. Most production is timed so that head development falls in the cool part of the season: spring plantings transplanted or direct-seeded for early-summer harvest, and mid- to late-summer plantings for fall harvest; in mild-winter zones (8 and warmer) fall and overwinter plantings extend supply. Marketed primarily as fresh crown-cut bunches and increasingly as processed florets (fresh-cut, frozen). It is among the more labor-intensive field vegetables because heads mature unevenly and are hand-cut over several passes.

26/30

Crop Snowflake Score

Gross Revenue
$8,100

/acre

Net Return
$1,500

/acre

Price Trend
declining
Establishment Cost

/acre

Crop Insurance
Available
Years to Production
0

years

Overview

Optimal growing temperature is about 60-70F; sustained heat above roughly 80F during head formation causes uneven 'riced' or loose heads, bracting (small leaves in the head), premature flowering, and bitter flavor, while plants exposed to prolonged cold (about 10 days below 40F) after reaching a juvenile threshold can 'button' into tiny premature heads. Broccoli is a heavy feeder, especially of nitrogen and boron; boron and molybdenum deficiencies cause hollow stem and whiptail respectively, so tissue testing and balanced fertility are important. Typical fresh-market yield is on the order of 150-160 cwt/acre. Major insect pests include cabbage looper, diamondback moth, imported cabbageworm, aphids, flea beetles, and harlequin bug; key diseases include black rot (Xanthomonas), downy mildew, Alternaria, white mold (Sclerotinia), and clubroot. Rotate at least 3 years away from other brassicas and manage soil pH near neutral to suppress clubroot. Heads are highly perishable and respire fast: harvest in the cool of the morning, cool immediately (hydro- or package-icing/vacuum cooling), and hold at 32F and 95-100% relative humidity, where quality lasts only about 10-14 days. Spacing and single- vs multiple-harvest systems vary by whether the crop is grown for one large central crown or for repeated side-shoot picking.

Growing Season

Plant
early spring – late summer
Harvest
late spring – late fall
Frost-free days
55+
GDD (base 50°F)
1,000 – 1,400

Yield

Typical yield
158 cwt/acre
Productive lifespan
1 years
Labor
150 hrs/acre
100%

Market Fit

4/6

Active Regional Buyers

1 active buyer on record purchasing this crop.

Price Trend Stable/Up

3-year price trend recorded as "increasing".

Supply Below Demand

Commodity vegetable — regional and national supply is well established, limiting headroom for new entrants.

Multiple Buyer Channels

1 recorded buyer and 6 documented market channels. Multiple routes to market.

Value-Added Potential

6 documented market channels, including value-added and direct-to-consumer routes.

Market Growth Projected

Mature vegetable market; growth over a 5-year horizon expected to track population rather than outpace it.

Market Channels

wholesale · Dominant outlet. Fresh-market accounts for ~95% of the U.S. broccoli crop; growers commonly contract with shippers to pack and ship at a predetermined price. Processing (mostly frozen) is contracted between grower and processor.
retail · Broccoli is among the most popular vegetables (6th by household purchase) and a year-round grocery staple; value-added pre-cut/bagged florets and broccoli slaw expand retail demand.
farmers_market · Cool-season fresh broccoli sells well direct; local-fresh quality commands a premium over wholesale prices, though scale is limited relative to wholesale.
direct_to_consumer · Roadside stands and farm stands are established broccoli outlets for small and mid-scale growers.
csa · A reliable cool-season CSA box staple in spring and fall shares.
restaurant · Steady foodservice demand, but pricing follows wholesale commodity markets; consistent supply and grade required.

Climate Fit

6/6

Hardiness Zone Match

Crop tolerates zones 3-10; region spans 5-6. Overlaps.

GDD Sufficient

Crop needs 1000 GDD (base 50F); region accumulates 2500+. Sufficient.

Precipitation Compatible

Crop needs ~20 in; region receives ~38 in/yr. Compatible, irrigation available as supplement.

Frost-Free Season OK

Crop needs 55 frost-free days; region provides ~180. Sufficient.

Chill Hours Met

Not applicable — biennial crop has no winter chill requirement.

Climate Trend Favorable

Crop spans 8 hardiness zones (3-10). Wide adaptive range buffers against warming trend.

Soil Compatibility

Soil Texture

loam (ideal)silt_loam (ideal)sandy_loam (suitable)clay_loam (suitable)silty_clay_loam (suitable)sandy_clay_loam (suitable)loamy_sand (marginal)silty_clay (marginal)clay (marginal)sand (poor)

Drainage

well_drained (ideal)moderately_well_drained (suitable)somewhat_poorly_drained (marginal)somewhat_excessively_drained (marginal)excessively_drained (marginal)poorly_drained (poor)very_poorly_drained (poor)

Infrastructure Fit

6/6

Equipment Compatible

11 documented equipment requirements. Within range adaptable from general row-crop or orchard equipment.

Storage Available

4 documented storage/handling requirements, all achievable with conventional on-farm or third-party facilities.

Irrigation Compatible

Requires ~20 in. Deliverable with conventional drip or overhead irrigation.

Field Layout Suitable

Suited to the small-to-mid-size fragmented parcels typical of the region.

Labor Availability

150 labor hr/ac vs catalog 75th percentile 250 hr/ac. Manageable with typical farm labor.

Processing Proximity

1 processor/cooperative buyer on record for this crop, 1 within NY/PA/OH.

Equipment Requirements

planting

Vegetable transplanter (water-wheel or carousel)Required Specialized

Broccoli is most commonly established from transplants for uniform stand and maturity. Water-wheel or carousel transplanters set plugs at uniform spacing with starter water. Typical range $8,000-20,000 depending on rows and automation.

$14,000
Precision vacuum/plate seederOptional Specialized

Used where broccoli is direct-seeded rather than transplanted; meters single seeds at target spacing to reduce thinning. Typical range $3,000-15,000.

$9,000

irrigation

Drip irrigation systemRequired

Consistent soil moisture is critical for uniform head development and quality; drip delivers precise water and fuels fertigation while keeping foliage dry to limit disease. Typical installed cost $500-1,500 per acre.

$1,000

cultivation

Bed shaper / plastic mulch layerOptional Specialized

Forms raised beds and lays drip tape and (optionally) plastic mulch in one pass for weed suppression and soil warming. Typical range $5,000-15,000.

$8,000
Row-crop cultivatorRequired

Mechanical between-row weed control reduces herbicide reliance and competition during establishment. Typical range $3,000-12,000.

$6,000

spraying

Boom sprayerRequired

Delivers fungicide and insecticide programs with good canopy penetration for disease and caterpillar/aphid management. Typical range $4,000-20,000 depending on capacity.

$8,000

harvesting

Field-pack harvest aid / mobile conveyorOptional Specialized

Broccoli is hand-cut; a mobile harvest conveyor (harvest rig) moves cut heads to packers riding or walking alongside, increasing field-pack throughput. Typical range $15,000-60,000.

$30,000
Harvest knives and field bins/totesRequired

Hand harvest of broccoli requires sharp knives and clean field containers to move heads quickly to cooling. Low fixed cost shared across vegetable operations.

$1,500

post_harvest

Hydrocooler or forced-air/ice coolingRequired Specialized

Broccoli has a very high respiration rate and must be cooled to near 0C immediately after cutting to preserve quality and shelf life; hydrocooling or package icing is standard. Typical range $10,000-50,000.

$25,000
Refrigerated cold storage (0C, high humidity)Required

Short-term holding at 0C and 95-100% relative humidity maintains quality before shipment. Cost varies widely with size; shared cooler infrastructure.

$20,000

general

Utility tractor (40-80 HP)Required

General-purpose power unit for bed prep, transplanting, cultivation, and spraying. Fixed cost shared across the vegetable operation. Typical range $25,000-60,000.

$35,000

Storage Requirements

Fresh cold storage

Temperature

32–32°F

Humidity

95–100%

Max Storage

28 days

Package icing (top-ice)

Temperature

32–34°F

Humidity

95–100%

Max Storage

21 days

Controlled atmosphere (1-2% O2, 5-10% CO2)

Temperature

32–41°F

Humidity

95–100%

Max Storage

35 days

Frozen (IQF, blanched)

Temperature

-10–0°F

Max Storage

365 days

Finance Fit

4/6

Revenue Above Average

Gross revenue $8,100/ac vs catalog median $5,500/ac. Above median.

Input Costs Acceptable

Input cost $6,600/ac vs catalog 75th percentile $5,387/ac. Above the top quartile.

Payback Period OK

Reaches full production in 0 years. Acceptable payback.

Insurance Available

Federal crop insurance or an equivalent risk product is available.

Revenue Per Labor Hour

Net return per labor hour $10.00 ($1,500/ac over 150 hr/ac) vs catalog median $13.16. Below median.

Grants/Subsidies

Vegetable crops are eligible under the USDA Specialty Crop Block Grant Program.

Economics Breakdown

Avg Price/Unit$82/per cwt (fresh market)
Gross Revenue/Acre$8,100
Annual Operating Cost$6,600/acre
Establishment Cost—/acre
Total Input Cost$6,600/acre
Net Return/Acre$1,500
Revenue/Labor Hour
Crop Insurance Available

Source: USDA NASS Vegetables 2024 Summary (Feb 2025); Cornell Dyson School Eastern Broccoli Production Enterprise Budgets EB 2020-12 (NY chapter) (2026)

Risk Fit

6/6

Manageable Pest/Disease

11 documented risk factors. Within the range manageable by conventional IPM.

Market Diversified

1 buyer, 6 channels. Not dependent on a single outlet.

Low Establishment Risk

0 years to full production. Low establishment exposure.

Climate Resilient

Tolerates zones 3-10 (8 zones). Broad tolerance indicates resilience to seasonal variability.

Regulatory Burden Low

No crop-specific licensing or reporting regime beyond standard food-safety and pesticide rules.

Diversifies Portfolio

Adds a vegetable revenue stream distinct from the region's grape-dominated base.

Known Risks

disease

Black rot (Xanthomonas campestris pv. campestris)high

The most serious bacterial disease of broccoli and other brassicas. Produces V-shaped yellow lesions advancing from leaf margins with blackened veins; systemic infection blackens vascular tissue and can collapse the plant. Seedborne and spread by splashing water, equipment, and movement through wet fields.

Downy mildew (Hyaloperonospora parasitica)moderate

Foliar disease favored by cool, moist conditions and prolonged leaf wetness. Causes angular yellow leaf lesions with grayish sporulation on the underside, and can discolor and downgrade harvested heads. Most damaging on transplants and early in field development.

Clubroot (Plasmodiophora brassicae)high

Soilborne pathogen causing swollen, distorted root galls that disrupt water and nutrient uptake, leading to wilting, stunting, and unmarketable plants. Resting spores persist in soil for many years and are favored by acidic, wet, poorly drained soils.

Alternaria leaf spot (Alternaria brassicae / A. brassicicola)moderate

Fungal disease producing dark concentric target-spot lesions on leaves and on the head, directly reducing marketability of the harvested curd. Spreads by spores in warm, wet weather and survives on crop residue and seed.

pest

Caterpillar complex — imported cabbageworm, cabbage looper, diamondback mothhigh

Larvae of imported cabbageworm (Pieris rapae), cabbage looper (Trichoplusia ni), and diamondback moth (Plutella xylostella) defoliate plants and bore into and contaminate heads with frass, making them unmarketable. Diamondback moth has developed widespread resistance to many insecticide classes.

Cabbage aphid (Brevicoryne brassicae)moderate

Waxy gray-green aphids form dense colonies in growing points and within developing heads, where they are difficult to dislodge and contaminate the product. Heavy feeding distorts growth and the species can transmit brassica viruses.

Flea beetles (Phyllotreta spp.)moderate

Small jumping beetles chew numerous tiny "shothole" pits in cotyledons and young leaves. Damage is most severe at establishment and can kill or set back seedlings and new transplants.

Cabbage maggot (Delia radicum)moderate

Larvae tunnel into roots and lower stems of seedlings and transplants in cool, wet soils, causing wilting, stunting, and stand loss; tunnels also provide entry for soft-rot organisms.

weather

Heat stress, bolting, and uneven headshigh

Broccoli is a cool-season crop; sustained temperatures above roughly 75-80F during head development cause premature bolting, loose or uneven heads, bracting, and "buttoning" (tiny heads), sharply reducing marketable yield.

Frost and freeze injury to headsmoderate

While broccoli tolerates light frost, a hard freeze can injure developing or mature curds, causing browning and a water-soaked appearance that makes heads unmarketable.

environmental

Boron deficiency (hollow stem / brown bead)moderate

Broccoli has a relatively high boron requirement; deficiency causes hollow, discolored or corky stems and browning of flower buds ("brown bead"), downgrading quality even when yield appears normal. Aggravated by high pH and uneven moisture.

Nutritional Yield

USDA FoodData Central
Profile based on Broccoli, raw (head form)
Edible mass per acre4,372 kg
Computed: 158 cwt × 45.36 kg/unit × 61% edible

Macronutrients

NutrientPer 100 gPer acre
Calories34 kcal1,486,378 kcal
Protein2.8 g123,282 g
Total fat0.4 g16,175 g
Carbohydrates6.6 g290,281 g
Fiber2.6 g113,664 g
Sugar1.7 g74,319 g

Key micronutrients

Iron
0.7 mg /100g
31,913 mg / acre
Calcium
47 mg /100g
2,054,699 mg / acre
Potassium
316 mg /100g
13,814,573 mg / acre
Vitamin C
89.2 mg /100g
3,899,557 mg / acre
Vitamin A
623 IU /100g
27,235,694 IU / acre
Folate
63 mcg /100g
2,754,171 mcg / acre

Uncertainty: Per-acre values are estimates that compound the yield range, edible-fraction assumption, and a single representative nutrient panel. Treat them as order-of-magnitude planning numbers, not nutritional advice. Confidence: high.

Ecosystem Services

Pest suppression

  • Brassica residue biofumigation
    moderate

    Brassica tissue releases glucosinolate-derived isothiocyanates when chopped and incorporated, which can suppress some soilborne fungi, nematodes, and weed seeds. The effect is part of why brassicas are used as biofumigant rotation crops.

    Applies when: when residue is chopped and incorporated promptly into moist soil
    Evidence: Peer-reviewed·Confidence: high

Nutrient cycling

  • Residual nitrogen scavenging
    moderate

    The vigorous brassica root system takes up residual soil nitrogen, reducing the pool available for leaching over the cropping window and recycling nutrients within the rotation.

    Applies when: when grown in rotation following a nitrogen-rich crop or manure
    Evidence: Extension guidance·Confidence: medium

Pollinator support

  • Floral resources when bolted or grown for seed
    low

    Broccoli is harvested before flowering, so commercial fields provide little pollinator forage during normal production. Plants that bolt, are left after harvest, or are grown for seed produce abundant yellow flowers that bees and hoverflies readily forage.

    Applies when: only when plants flower (bolted, left after harvest, or grown for seed)
    Evidence: Extension guidance·Confidence: medium

Soil health

  • Organic matter and soil cover during the cropping window
    low

    The broad leaf canopy shades the soil surface during the season, and returned residue contributes some organic matter and supports soil biology. Heavy harvest and residue removal limit the net contribution compared with a dedicated cover crop.

    Applies when: when crop residue is returned to the soil rather than fully removed
    Evidence: Extension guidance·Confidence: medium

Biodiversity

  • Beneficial insect habitat from flowering and margins
    low

    Flowering brassica plants and unsprayed margins provide nectar and habitat for parasitoid wasps, hoverflies, and other natural enemies that help regulate aphids and caterpillars.

    Applies when: when some plants flower and unsprayed field margins are retained
    Evidence: Extension guidance·Confidence: medium

Nearby Buyers

Radius from Lake Erie Concord Grape Belt:

Eden Valley Growers

Eden, NY · 30.0 mi

cooperative
Accepts contracts

Data Sources

Every data point on this page is traceable to its source. Below you'll find the complete provenance trail — which sources were used, when data was last verified, and a full change history.

Primary sources: Production, yield, price, and market structure from USDA Agricultural Marketing Resource Center (AgMRC) Broccoli commodity profile — https://www.agmrc.org/commodities-products/vegetables/broccoli — drawing on USDA NASS Vegetables Annual Summary. Cool-season agronomy, physiological disorders (buttoning, hollow stem, bracting), pest/disease pressure, and post-harvest cooling cross-referenced with land-grant extension cole-crop production guides (e.g., Penn State, Cornell, UC).

Economics data year: 2026 · Region: lake_erie View economics source →

Crop Picker

by Every.Farm

A stock-screener-style tool for comparing crops anywhere in the world.

Your Location

  • Lake Erie Concord Grape Belt
  • NY / PA
  • United States
  • Zone 6a

Change this from the header to screen crops for a different region.

Experimental research database. AI-assisted, may contain errors. Not formal agricultural, financial, or planting advice. Verify with your local extension service before making decisions.

© 2026 Every.Farm · Data for informational purposes only.